Experience Key Lime Resorts in Monticello, IN. Enjoy 4.8-star hospitality, LGBTQ+ friendly amenities, boat rentals, and proximity to Indiana Beach Boardwalk.
Visitors appreciate the outstanding hospitality, peaceful location, and proximity to Indiana Beach, making it a memorable spot for family-friendly getaways and outdoor activities.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Key Lime Resorts is a multi-faceted property offering hotel accommodations, boat rentals, and vacation home rentals, situated on the scenic waterfront of Monticello, Indiana. The setting provides guests with easy access to outdoor recreation, including boating and tubing opportunities directly on-site, along with a peaceful atmosphere that visitors frequently appreciate. The resort’s location places it within walking distance of Indiana Beach Boardwalk Resort, a popular amusement destination, making it convenient for families and leisure travelers looking to combine relaxation with entertainment.
The property is noted for its friendly and accommodating host, who has been described as attentive and responsive by several guests. Amenities cater to an inclusive crowd, being LGBTQ+ friendly, and many reviews highlight the quality of the accommodations, cleanliness, and the peaceful environment, especially appreciated during nighttime. Guests mention well-maintained facilities such as decks and grills, which enhance the outdoor experience.
Located at 4974 E Indiana Beach Road, the resort benefits from proximity to a variety of local attractions and other well-rated nearby accommodations, all within a short distance. Access to the Purdue University Airport is roughly a 47-minute drive, adding to the convenience for travelers. The overall guest feedback reflects a high satisfaction level, with a 4.8 rating across 78 reviews, particularly valuing the combination of location, amenities, and the host’s hospitality.
This property is especially suitable for visitors seeking a mix of lakeside leisure, family activities, and easy access to regional attractions. Its offering appeals to guests wanting both the comforts of a vacation home and the convenience of hotel services, with the added benefit of boating options right on-site. Key Lime Resorts typically attracts those looking for a relaxed getaway near Indiana Beach with opportunities to explore the surrounding area.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Cabin was great. Less than 5 minutes walk from indiana beach. The host Mike was AMAZING! He gave us boat driving lessons and took us out to tube with the kids because he wanted them safe! 10/10.
RV #1 is a perfect size for a nice getaway . Loved being able to walk to the amusement park , especially since you have in and out privileges at the park . The RV is super clean , the host is very communicative, and the area is peaceful at night -the stars are really pretty at night . The new deck is really nice and the grill came in handy . Will stay again
Mike (the owner) did everything he could to accommodate our requests. He is honest and hard working. I would highly recommend this resort if you are visiting the Monticello area.
Great and convenient location coming from Chicago. Our family of 7 wanted a relaxing weekend. We rented a boat on the property and went tubing and had a great time! Mike was very accommodating and easy to work with. A must stay!
Couldn’t have asked for a better place to get away with my family. The property and the view is absolutely spectacular! Mike walked us through the home. Got us acquainted, and went above and beyond making sure we were comfortable before he left us to enjoy the property. We rented the boat and had a picnic on the lake. After enjoying the amusement park that is only 2 mins away. This was by far better that the rush of a hotel. Definitely a stay that will be happening again!
The host was excellent at responding to questions. We had left something behind and he made extra effort to help us get it back. The place was clean and was exactly as shown. We were able to rent his boat when ours broke. We had a great time and would return.
Fantastic location that offers everything you could possibly need! Indiana Beach is steps away along with many other activities, restaurants and more! The location has a BEAUTIFUL view of the lake and of Indiana Beach! They are very accommodating and cozy, stocked with anything you could need! 100% MUST! Worth every penny! Great communication! Cant say enough good things! Thanks for the unique and unforgettable experiences!
My family has been visiting Indiana Beach since I was too young to remember. This was one of the best experiences we've ever had! The location is PERFECT! walking distance to the North Park entrance, but somehow still quiet and relaxing. It's right on the water, with a beautiful lake view and views of the ferris wheel. Gorgeous at night. We stayed in the #4 suite, which was perfect for us. It's a walkout basement, so it stays very cool. It was also pretty private, which helped our dogs stay relaxed. We used the (very nice) grill and sat on the back patio a lot, as well. Mike was great! Very quick to answer any questions and so so nice! We're already talking about coming back!
Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Indiana. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
5,827 reviews 5224 E Indiana Beach Rd, Monticello, IN 47960, United States
42 reviews 5224 E Indiana Beach Rd, Monticello, IN 47960, United States
31 reviews 5087 E Indiana Beach Rd, Monticello, IN 47960, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Comfortable rooms with dining, gym, library & seasonal pool at Sleep Inn Fort Pierce I95. Located 2 miles from Indian River State...
4.2rated hotel with free breakfast, WiFi, and gym. Quiet Brooklyn location near Coney Island, Statue of Liberty, and Brooklyn Mu...
Stay at Cooper's Landing Inn & Traveler's Tavern in Clarksville, VA. Enjoy free WiFi, pool, bar, and nearby attractions like Occo...
Temple City Motel offers free WiFi and parking in South Salt Lake, UT. Rated 3.6/5 with 51 reviews, near Temple Square and Salt L...
Stay at Leland Hotel Palo Alto, rated 4.4 with 127 reviews. Enjoy LGBTQ+ friendly amenities near Cantor Arts Center and California...
Experience comfort at Pickle Factory Boutique Hotel in Covington, KY. Free WiFi, parking, kitchen in rooms, near MainStrasse Vill...
Stay at Mullin Hotel, Moorefield, WV. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, restaurant, bar, and close access to Lost River State Park and lo...
Stay at Wahoo Heritage Inn in Wahoo, NE. Enjoy free WiFi, petfriendly rooms, and easy access to Lake Wanahoo and Saunders County...
Stay at Mystic River Hotel & Suites in Mystic, CT. Enjoy free parking, heated indoor pool, gym, and easy access to Mystic Aquarium...
Stay at OurGuest Inn & Suites Downtown Port Clinton with heated outdoor pool, free WiFi, and kidfriendly rooms. Steps from downt...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
